Prior to 1846: Amos McKenney, Ebenezer Colliver, Peter Ten Broeck, Benjamin Pawling, George Rykert, Jacob Dittrick, George Adams, Charles Ingersoll, Robert Campbell, J.W. Clenennan, Peter S. Campbell, David M. Smith
Alpheus St. John..........1846 Marcius L. Goodenough.....1848 Frederick Parsons.........1850 R. Franklin Jr............1852 John L. Ranney............1854 F. Parsons................1856 William Poe...............1858 Theophilus Mack...........1860 C.P. Camp.................1862 W.H. Reid.................1864 Walter Chatfield..........1866 Lucius S. Oille...........1868 A. Chatfield..............1870 Levi Yale.................1872 Robert Kane...............1874 J.H. Taylor...............1876 A. McLaren................1878 J.D. Christie.............1880 C.G. McDermott............1882 W.B. Towers...............1884 Chas. H. Connor...........1886 George Burch..............1888 Chas. H. Connor...........1890 J.A. Leeper...............1892 C.G. McGhie...............1894 J.E. Hetherington.........1896 W.H. Merritt..............1898 Thomas W. Wilson..........1900 W.T. Dean.................1902 H. O'Loughlin.............1904 A.T. Riddell..............1906 F.C. McCordick............1908 George E. Burch...........1910 W.P. Homes................1912 F.P. Gwinner..............1914 P.C. Miller...............1916 W.V. Carlson..............1918 A.A. Henderson............1920 F.E. Moore................1922 Ellis Coates..............1924 Arthur Dean...............1926 Horton W. Byrne...........1928 William A. Darker.........1930 C.H. Hesburn..............1932 Chas. W. Glass............1934 Fred Fitzpatrick..........1936 Edward L. Missen..........1938 Corbin A. Brown...........1940 Arthur J. Whitelock.......1942 John W. Preston...........1944 Merlyn M. Statton.........1946 Donald D. Webster.........1948 Stanley F. Town...........1950 Frederick L. Riches.......1952 Chas. M. Porter...........1954 Arthur J. Tigert..........1956 Roland E. Westlake........1958 James M. Wilcox...........1960 John O'Connell............1962 James B. Thompson.........1964 W. Atkins.................1966 Albert Kinnear............1968 George Peters.............1970 John Dundas...............1972 Tom Linders...............1974 Ross Simmons..............1976 Thomas Silagy.............1978 Paul Hansell..............1980 Gerald Hunt...............1982 Brian Cullen..............1984 J.A. Robertson............1986 Peter Klotz...............1988 Brian Clement.............1990 Norman R. Rattew..........1992 Tony Robles...............1994 Peter J. Edmonds..........1996 Allister MacDonald........1998 David E. Gillis...........2000 Donald Bowman.............2002 Dan Monteith..............2004 Tony Maddaloni............2006 Tony Maddaloni............2008 Dave Osborne..............2010 Richard Green.............2012 Mark Anderson McGaw.......2014 Chuck Cossette............2016 Dan Monteith..............2018 Jim Thwaites..............2020 Scott de Haan.............2022	George Rykert.............1847 Frederick Parsons.........1849 A. Roberts................1851 Frederick.................1853 Thomas Fletcher...........1855 William Poe...............1857 Samuel J. Dolson..........1859 Andrew A. Henderson.......1861 F.W. McDonald.............1863 Samuel G. Dolson..........1865 Lucius S. Oille...........1867 A. Chatfield..............1869 D.W. Bixby................1871 Levi Yale.................1873 William Duggan............1875 A. McLaren................1877 J.D. Christie.............1879 J.D. Christie.............1881 Wm. M. Shaw...............1883 George LeSeur.............1885 Johnston Clench...........1887 George Burch..............1889 Chas. H. Connor...........1891 Chas. Burch...............1893 J.E. Hetherington.........1895 W.H. Merritt..............1897 Thomas W. Wilson..........1899 A. McLaren................1901 H. O'Loughlin.............1903 K.F. Vine.................1905 A.T. Riddell..............1907 W.C. Burch................1909 E.W. Smith................1911 W.P. Homes................1913 Richard Wilson............1915 H.T. Harper...............1917 George H. Ruddle..........1919 Charles W. Karn...........1921 C.F. Monk.................1923 Chas. H. Burch............1925 Samuel Kearns.............1927 George F. Swan............1929 J.M. Shultis..............1931 W.H. Secord...............1933 George R. Grady...........1935 Robert Thompson...........1937 Harold E. Court...........1939 Walter E. Thompson........1941 Henry J. Fernay...........1943 L. Arthur Burch...........1945 Hugh Howes................1947 Gordon L. Talbot..........1949 John B. Sainsbury.........1951 Norman G. Andrews.........1953 John L. Pallister.........1955 William J. Gasking........1957 W. Allan Barnes...........1959 Howard W. Thompson........1961 John M. Shore.............1963 Robert Bowman.............1965 John Osborne..............1967 John Dore.................1969 Ron Penfound..............1971 Ian Todd..................1973 Ronald Lewis..............1975 Robert Lewis..............1977 Rodney Black..............1979 Paul Hansell..............1981 J.A. Robertson............1983 William Birdsall..........1985 Peter Klotz...............1987 Brian Clement.............1989 Brian Clement.............1991 Gerald Hunt...............1993 John Kernahan.............1995 Alex Crawford.............1997 David E. Gillis...........1999 Michael Kloss.............2001 Robert Houston............2003 Richard Green.............2005 John Fernandez............2007 Dave Osborne..............2009 Bradley Hart..............2011 Mark Anderson McGaw.......2013 Bradley Hart..............2015 Scott de Haan.............2017 Jim Thwaites..............2019 Jim Thwaites..............2021 Bradley Hart..............2023